Philosophy●●●●●Difficulty 2 of 5

What did Plato mean by prisoners watching shadows in a cave?

Long before The Matrix, Plato imagined people who mistake a puppet show for the whole of reality, and who would fight anyone trying to free them.

▶ Start the story

Plato meant that most of us may be taking copies for the real thing, and that learning to see past them is hard, painful and unpopular. In Book VII of the Republic, he has his teacher Socrates describe people chained in a cave since childhood, able to look only at the wall in front of them. Behind them burns a fire, and along a low wall people carry objects and puppets. The prisoners see only the shadows and hear the echoes, and since they have never seen anything else, those shadows are their reality.

Now free one prisoner. The firelight hurts his eyes, and he wants to run back to the familiar shadows. Dragged outside, he adjusts slowly: first shadows, then reflections in water, then the things themselves, then the stars, and at last the sun. For Plato, this ascent mirrors education, and the world outside stands for his theory of Forms, the idea that what we reach through reason is more real than what our senses show us.

Illustration of chained prisoners facing a cave wall with shadows on it, a fire and people carrying objects behind them, and an exit toward daylight.
The setup: prisoners see only the shadows cast by objects carried in front of a fire behind them.Photo: 4edges · CC BY-SA 4.0

The twist is the return. Back in the dark, the freed man is blinded, and the others conclude the trip outside ruined his eyes. If they could, Socrates says, they would kill anyone who tried to drag them out. Scholars still argue over whether the story is mostly about knowledge or about politics, and films like The Truman Show and The Matrix keep retelling it.

The freed prisoner's climb
  1. Step 1: Shadows

    All he has ever known

  2. Step 2: The fire

    The light hurts; he wants to run back

  3. Step 3: Reflections

    People and things mirrored in water

  4. Step 4: Things themselves

    Then the stars and moon at night

  5. Step 5: The sun

    Finally he can look at it directly

Quiz me

0/3

  1. 1.Why do the prisoners take the shadows for reality?
  2. 2.What do the prisoners conclude when the freed man comes back blinded?
  3. 3.Which idea of Plato's is the world outside the cave tied to?

Recap

Shadows, fire, sun: Plato's cave is a ladder from appearances to reality, and the hardest step is going back down.

Surprising fact · Back in the cave, the freed prisoner is blinded by the dark, so the others conclude that leaving is harmful.

Sources (1)

No source, no claim. Every fact in this lesson (15 claims) cites at least one of these.

  1. [1]Allegory of the cave · Wikipedia
More lessons in 🤔 Philosophy (3) See all philosophy lessons →

One more light on your map.

Get one lesson like this every day, about the things you love. Free, in two or five minutes.

Get the share card for this lesson ↗