Language●●●●●Difficulty 3 of 5

How can linguists rebuild a language no one ever wrote down?

Nobody has ever read a single word of Proto-Indo-European, yet linguists know how its speakers said 'water', 'hound' and 'three'.

▶ Start the story

Linguists rebuild an unwritten language by comparing its descendants. Proto-Indo-European, the ancestor of languages from English and French to Hindi and Persian, left no written record at all. But when sounds change, they change regularly, so the daughter languages keep matching patterns. Compare Italian piede, padre, pesce with English foot, father, fish: the p and the f line up far too often to be a coincidence. Collect enough of these correspondences and you can work backwards to the parent word.

That is how linguists know that the ancestors of English water, hound and three were something like *wódr̥, *ḱwn̥tós and *tréyes, the asterisk meaning 'reconstructed, never seen'. The language was probably spoken between about 4500 and 2500 BCE, perhaps on the steppes north of the Black and Caspian seas, before migrations split it into dialects that became separate languages.

A pattern too regular to be chance

Italian

  • piede
  • padre
  • pesce

English

  • foot
  • father
  • fish

The idea caught on thanks to William Jones, a British judge in India who learned Sanskrit to check the court's legal experts. In 1786 he declared that Sanskrit, Greek and Latin were too alike to be an accident and must share a common source that perhaps no longer exists. A French Jesuit, Gaston-Laurent Coeurdoux, had noticed the same thing twenty years earlier. Today over 3.4 billion people speak a descendant of that lost language.

A branching family-tree diagram with Proto-Indo-European at the root and branches such as Germanic, Italic, Celtic, Hellenic, Indo-Iranian and Balto-Slavic leading to individual languages.
One lost ancestor, many descendants: a partial tree of the Indo-European languages.Photo: Multiple authors, first version by Mandrak · CC BY-SA 3.0

Quiz me

0/3

  1. 1.Why can linguists reconstruct words of a language that was never written?
  2. 2.What does the asterisk in a form like *tréyes mean?
  3. 3.Why is Saussure's 1879 proposal a striking success of the method?

Recap

Sounds change by rules, so matching patterns in daughter languages let you run the film backwards to the parent.

Surprising fact · A French Jesuit, Coeurdoux, spotted the Sanskrit–European connection in 1767, before William Jones's famous 1786 lecture.

Sources (3)

No source, no claim. Every fact in this lesson (16 claims) cites at least one of these.

  1. [1]Proto-Indo-European language · Wikipedia
  2. [2]William Jones (philologist) · Wikipedia
  3. [3]Indo-European languages · Wikipedia
More lessons in 🗣 Language (3) See all language lessons →

One more light on your map.

Get one lesson like this every day, about the things you love. Free, in two or five minutes.

Get the share card for this lesson ↗