Why do some volcanoes explode and others just ooze lava?
Hawaiian lava can flow calmly enough that you could, very carefully, walk near it, while volcanoes like Mount St Helens blast ash and rock high into the sky, and the difference is mostly a matter of how much silica and gas the magma happens to be carrying.
▶ Start the storyMostly because of how much silica and dissolved gas the magma carries. Magma is molten rock under the ground, often mixed with crystals and gas bubbles. It forms where the mantle or crust melts: at subduction zones, rifts, mid-ocean ridges and hotspots. What it does at the surface depends on its chemistry.
Silica is the key ingredient. Each silicon atom grabs four oxygen atoms and forms a tiny pyramid. When there is a lot of silica, those pyramids link up into chains and clumps. The magma turns thick and sticky. Low-silica magma, the kind that builds Hawaii's gentle shield volcanoes, is about as runny as ketchup. It erupts at 1,100 to 1,200 °C and simply flows away. High-silica magma can be ten million times stickier, even though it erupts cooler.
Mafic magma (e.g. Hawaii)
- 45-52% silica
- Viscosity like ketchup
- Flows calmly, builds shield volcanoes
Felsic magma
- Over 63% silica
- Up to 10 million times stickier
- Traps gas, erupts explosively
Stickiness is what makes a volcano explode. Deep down, magma holds gases like water vapour and carbon dioxide, the way a closed soda bottle holds its fizz. As magma rises, the pressure drops and the gas forms bubbles. In runny magma, the bubbles slip out fairly gently. In sticky magma, they stay trapped. Pressure builds until the magma shatters and blasts ash and rock into the sky.
That's why so many explosive volcanoes sit above subduction zones. There, a sinking ocean plate releases water into the hot mantle above it. The water lowers the melting point, so new magma forms. That magma is loaded with dissolved water and gas. It feeds the volcanic arcs of the Pacific Ring of Fire, where some of the planet's most violent eruptions happen.
Quiz me
0/3
Recap
High silica plus trapped gas means an explosive eruption; low silica plus easily escaping gas means a calm, flowing one.
Surprising fact · Magma has only ever been directly encountered three times by drilling, and one of those strikes, in Iceland in 2009, was turned into a 36-megawatt geothermal power source.
Sources (1)
No source, no claim. Every fact in this lesson (15 claims) cites at least one of these.