How close did Quebec come to leaving Canada in the 1995 referendum?

On 30 October 1995, 93.52% of Quebec's voters turned out, and the No side won by 54,288 votes.

Very close. On 30 October 1995 Quebecers voted on whether Quebec should become sovereign, and the No side won by 54,288 votes, with 50.58 percent of the votes cast. Turnout was 93.52 percent, the largest in Quebec's history and higher than at any provincial or federal election in Canadian history.

It was the second such vote. After the Parti Québécois won power in 1976, it held a referendum in 1980 seeking a mandate to negotiate "" with Canada, and that was decisively defeated, with 59.6 percent voting no. In 1995 the early predictions were again of a heavy sovereignist defeat. Then the Yes side flourished after leader Lucien Bouchard took it over.

Share of the vote, 1995 Quebec referendum

%

Bar chart: Share of the vote, 1995 Quebec referendum. (%)
Votes cast
No50.6%
Yes49.4%
The No side won by 54,288 votes.

The question itself was long: it asked whether Quebec should become sovereign, after having made a formal offer to Canada for a new economic and political partnership. Voters split sharply. Yes was the choice of French speakers by an estimated majority of about 60 percent, while anglophones and , people whose first language is neither English nor French, voted No by a margin of 95 percent. The closest result in any was in Vimont, in Laval, which Yes won by 6 votes.

What would a Yes have meant? The two sides disagreed. believed that 50 percent plus one vote was binding. The No campaign head, Daniel Johnson, disputed that a simple majority was enough. After the close result, the federal government referred the issue to the Supreme Court of Canada, which stated that the unilateral secession contemplated in the referendum was illegal.

Try it

How many voters would it have taken?

-80-4004080015304560Voters who change their vote (thousands)No lead over Yes (thousands of votes)

y = −1x + 54.3

Challenge · Set the change to -2, so each switch from No to Yes closes the gap by two. How many thousand voters switching would have tied the vote (about 27)?

A simple model using the real margin of 54,288 votes; at -1 the line shows voters who stay home instead of switching.

Quiz me

0/3

  1. 1.What was the margin of the No victory in the 1995 Quebec referendum?
  2. 2.Why was it disputed what a Yes vote would have meant?
  3. 3.What did the federal government do after the close result?

Recap

A 50.58% to 49.42% result, on a very high turnout, left the rules for the next time to be argued out in court and in Parliament.

💡 A trick to remember it · Fifty point five eight to forty-nine point four two: a whisker, with almost everyone voting.

Surprising fact · Turnout was 93.52%, higher than at any provincial or federal election in Canada's history.

Sources (2)

No source, no claim. Every fact in this lesson (16 claims) cites at least one of these.

  1. [1]1995 Quebec referendum · Wikipedia
  2. [2]Reference Re Secession of Quebec · Wikipedia
More lessons in ⚖️ Society & law (3) See all society & law lessons →

One more light on your map.

Get one lesson like this every day, about the things you love. Free, in two or five minutes.

Get the share card for this lesson ↗