What was the longest papal conclave, and how did Viterbo invent the lock-in?
One town ran out of patience, cut the cardinals' food and took the roof off their palace, and that is where conclaves come from.
The longest papal election in the history of the Catholic Church began on 1 December 1268, after the death of Pope Clement IV, and ended on 1 September 1271, almost three years later. It took place in the Italian town of Viterbo and dragged on primarily because of political infighting between the cardinals. It is also where the idea of locking cardinals in came from: the rules of the conclave, issued by Pope Gregory X in 1274, were based on the tactics used against the cardinals in Viterbo.
The deadlock had a clear shape. The French cardinals, mostly created by Pope Urban IV, were amenable to an invasion of Italy by Charles of Anjou. The non-French cardinals, mostly Italian, had just enough numbers to prevent a French pope from being elected. Of the twenty cardinal-electors, three died during the election and one resigned.
In late 1269, after months of deadlock, the town's officials ordered the cardinals in the Palace of the Popes until a pope was elected. The later reduced their rations to bread and water and removed the roof of the palace. According to one account, by Onofrio Panvinio, Cardinal John of Toledo suggested it himself: "Let us uncover the Room, else the Holy Ghost will never get at us". Other sources say Charles of Anjou orchestrated the hardships, and some say a makeshift roof was put back after the cardinals threatened to put all of Viterbo under .
1 Dec 1268
The election begins after Clement IV's death
Late 1269
Cardinals are in the Palace of the Popes
1 Sep 1271
Cardinals cede their choice to a committee of six
12 Feb 1272
Visconti reaches Viterbo and becomes Gregory X
7 Jul 1274
Ubi periculum sets the conclave rules
In the end the cardinals ceded their authority to a committee of six, which chose Teobaldo Visconti, who was not even a cardinal and was in Acre as papal to a crusade. He took the name Gregory X, and in 1274 his bull Ubi periculum set the rules: seclusion for the whole election, meals passed through a small opening, one meal a day after three days, and bread and water after eight.
Quiz me
0/3
Recap
A stalemate of almost three years, ended by locking cardinals in, led to the conclave's rule of seclusion.
π‘ A trick to remember it Β· No roof, no dinner, no choice: the town of Viterbo made the cardinals pick a pope.
Surprising fact Β· The roof of the palace was removed, though sources disagree on who ordered it.
Connects to
- ποΈ How did Vatican City become the world's smallest country? The Papal States and the 1929 Lateran Treaty
- π¨ How is a pope chosen? Inside a conclave, with cardinals, two-thirds and white smoke
- π¦ How did a family of bankers turn Florence into the capital of art?
- π Did the Black Death make workers richer?
- Pope gregory x
Sources (1)
No source, no claim. Every fact in this lesson (14 claims) cites at least one of these.